The Shining Rise and Turbulent Fall of Actress Frances Farmer

 

The Shining Rise and Turbulent Fall of 

Actress Frances Farmer

 

Frances Farmer's life reads like a gothic novel from Old Hollywood—rich with promise, laced with rebellion, and ultimately marred by cruelty, misunderstanding, and tragedy. Born with beauty, intellect, and fierce independence, Farmer rose quickly in the 1930s film industry, only to be crushed under its weight in one of the most tragic downfalls in Hollywood history.

A Promising Start

Frances Elena Farmer was born on September 19, 1913, in Seattle, Washington. From an early age, she demonstrated a fiery spirit and a hunger for truth. At just 16, she penned an essay titled God Dies, which earned her both acclaim and condemnation—foreshadowing a life marked by public scrutiny and defiance of convention. That same unflinching voice followed her into college at the University of Washington, where she studied journalism and drama.

Farmer’s beauty and intelligence did not go unnoticed. She won a drama competition in college that earned her a trip to the Soviet Union in 1935. This rare and controversial journey would later be used to paint her as un-American during the Red Scare, though it was motivated more by her intellectual curiosity than political alignment. When she returned to the States, she moved to New York City and began acting in stock theater before catching the attention of Paramount Pictures.

A Meteoric Hollywood Rise

Farmer signed a seven-year contract with Paramount and made her film debut in Too Many Parents (1936), followed quickly by a breakout performance opposite Bing Crosby in Rhythm on the Range the same year. Critics and audiences alike took notice—not only was she stunning, but she brought a rawness and depth that defied the glossier mold of Hollywood starlets.

Throughout the late 1930s, she starred in a series of well-received films, including Come and Get It (1936), produced by Samuel Goldwyn and directed in part by Howard Hawks. Her role in that film earned her critical praise and should have cemented her as one of Hollywood's next great leading ladies. Yet from the beginning, Frances was uneasy with the industry. She bristled at being objectified and refused to play the publicity game that so many of her peers embraced. She loathed the phoniness of studio life, once calling it “a gilded cage.”

That candor, combined with her aversion to being controlled, made her difficult in the eyes of studio executives. As a woman in a patriarchal industry, her assertiveness was interpreted as arrogance. As she fought for better roles and more autonomy, the very system that had built her began slowly turning against her.

Personal Battles and Professional Setbacks

Farmer’s personal life became increasingly turbulent. She married actor Leif Erickson in 1936, though the union was short-lived. Meanwhile, her frustrations with Hollywood mounted. She turned to the stage and joined the Group Theatre in New York, where she starred in Clifford Odets’ Golden Boy. But even there, she found disappointment. Her return to Hollywood was met with inferior roles and mounting tension with studio bosses.

By the early 1940s, Farmer’s life began to unravel. She was arrested in 1942 for driving with bright headlights during wartime restrictions. The incident, and her combative response to police, ignited a media frenzy. Soon, she was portrayed as an unhinged woman spiraling out of control. Over the next several years, Farmer faced multiple arrests, erratic behavior, and ultimately institutionalization.

What followed remains one of the darkest chapters in Hollywood lore.

Institutionalization and Alleged Abuse

In 1943, Farmer’s mother declared her mentally unfit, and Frances was committed to various psychiatric institutions, including the infamous Western State Hospital in Washington. There, she would spend the better part of seven years, subject to what she later described as cruel and inhumane treatment.

Farmer recounted being beaten, drugged, and even subjected to insulin shock therapy and hydrotherapy—common practices at the time, but deeply traumatic. She later alleged she was raped repeatedly by hospital orderlies. Though some details of her treatment remain disputed, the prevailing consensus is that she endured horrifying abuse while institutionalized. Her free spirit—so bold and brilliant in her youth—was methodically broken down.

Despite the trauma, she was eventually released in 1950. Though the years in the asylum had left deep psychological scars, Frances Farmer was not completely defeated.

The Attempted Comeback

After her release, Farmer attempted a modest return to public life. In the 1950s, she worked sporadically in theater and television. She even hosted a local TV show in Indianapolis titled Frances Farmer Presents. Her appearances, though restrained, reminded viewers of the striking talent that had once promised so much.

In 1958, she published her autobiography Will There Really Be a Morning?, though many later suspected it had been heavily edited or ghostwritten. Still, the memoir further exposed the torment she endured during her institutionalization and painted a picture of a woman repeatedly betrayed by those around her.

Her final years were quiet but somber. Farmer died of esophageal cancer on August 1, 1970, at just 56 years old.

Legacy of a Misunderstood Icon

Frances Farmer’s life story has been the subject of books, plays, and films—including the 1982 biopic Frances, starring Jessica Lange, which brought her tragic story back into the public consciousness.

Today, Farmer is remembered as a cautionary tale—a woman ahead of her time who refused to be molded by the Hollywood machine and paid dearly for it. She was neither the hysterical madwoman the tabloids portrayed, nor the flawless victim sometimes romanticized after her death. She was a real, complicated woman—brilliant, proud, and ultimately crushed by a system that had no place for someone so fiercely independent.

In a more forgiving era, Frances Farmer might have flourished. But in the rigid, image-obsessed world of mid-century Hollywood, her refusal to conform marked the beginning of her undoing. Her story remains one of the most haunting examples of how the very industry that creates stars can also destroy them.

This article is owned and copyrighted by Behind the Silver Screen and cannot be reproduced in any way without the permission of the owner.

Learn More: